BREAKING: Alvin Kamara to Sign with the 49ers on a 5-Year, $50M Deal — But the 49ers Didn’t Agree. The Reason Is…
San Francisco, CA – July 6, 2025 —
In a whirlwind 48 hours that sent shockwaves through NFL circles, New Orleans Saints running back Alvin Kamara was reportedly on the brink of signing a five-year, $50 million contract with the San Francisco 49ers. The news generated excitement across the Bay Area and sparked heavy buzz online — but by midday Sunday, that excitement turned to confusion.
The 49ers had not agreed to the deal.
While Kamara’s representatives were said to be “finalizing paperwork,” insiders from the 49ers front office abruptly issued a statement halting the transaction before it could be made official.
“While we have great respect for Alvin Kamara and his incredible career, we are not pursuing him at this time,” said 49ers General Manager John Lynch in an unexpected press briefing. “We are committed to the roster we’ve built, and after internal discussions, we’ve decided to move in a different direction.”
A Deal That Was Never Signed
Reports indicate that Kamara’s camp had initiated conversations with the 49ers shortly after the start of July’s free agency window. With Kamara looking to leave New Orleans after eight seasons and five Pro Bowl appearances, the 49ers were one of the first teams in contact.
Initial terms of the contract were leaked to the media on Saturday: a five-year, $50 million deal with $22 million guaranteed and additional performance-based incentives. Many believed the move would pair Kamara with Christian McCaffrey, forming one of the most dangerous backfields in NFL history.
But the deal was never finalized.
NFL insider Tom Pelissero noted, “There was excitement from Kamara’s camp, even a sense of urgency. But once it reached San Francisco’s leadership for approval, something changed. The 49ers pumped the brakes fast.”
Scheme Fit and Culture Clash
Sources close to the organization have now revealed the key reasons the 49ers backed out — and it wasn’t just about money.
The most significant concern? Scheme fit and locker room balance.
Head coach Kyle Shanahan is known for his intricate zone-blocking run game and his tendency to maximize versatility. While Kamara possesses elite receiving skills and open-field vision, the staff reportedly felt that his style might not fully align with the timing-based rhythm of the 49ers’ offense — especially with McCaffrey already operating as the primary option.
One anonymous team executive stated:
“Alvin’s a baller. That’s not in question. But this offense is already firing with Christian. Adding another alpha in that same role could disrupt the flow. We’re focused on balance, not headlines.”
Another concern that reportedly emerged was Kamara’s fit in the locker room. While not known as a distraction, Kamara is a vocal leader and public figure, whereas the 49ers’ culture is rooted in discipline, humility, and a “next-man-up” ethos.
McCaffrey’s Position
There’s also the reality that Christian McCaffrey, the reigning NFL Offensive Player of the Year, is the heartbeat of the 49ers’ offensive identity. The organization has invested heavily in him — both financially and schematically — and giving Kamara a large contract could have triggered questions about roles, touches, and value.
Former NFL running back and current analyst Maurice Jones-Drew noted on NFL Network:
“If you’re the 49ers, you don’t want to create confusion in your offensive game plan. Kamara’s a star, but this isn’t Madden. You can’t just stack stars. You have to consider chemistry and consistency.”
What’s Next for Kamara?
With San Francisco officially pulling out of the deal, Kamara’s free agency is once again wide open. Sources say his agent is now in renewed talks with multiple AFC teams — including the Baltimore Ravens, Cincinnati Bengals, and Houston Texans — all of whom have cap space and potential need for a dual-threat back.
Kamara has yet to issue a statement publicly, though he posted a cryptic message on X (formerly Twitter) late Sunday afternoon:
“Timing is everything. Back to work.”
It’s unclear whether Kamara was blindsided by the 49ers’ reversal, but those close to him say he remains motivated and confident a deal will be reached elsewhere.
Final Thoughts
This dramatic episode underscores a key truth in today’s NFL: talent alone doesn’t seal a deal. For teams like the 49ers — who are chasing a Super Bowl and trying to manage one of the deepest rosters in the league — every move is about fit, chemistry, and long-term vision.
Alvin Kamara is still one of the league’s most electrifying backs. But as of now, he won’t be wearing red and gold.
Stay tuned.
Leave a Reply